MARCH 3, 2005
ITEM NO.: A
FILE
NO.:
LU04-17-02
Name:
Land Use Plan Amendment - Crystal Valley Planning District
Location:
17415 Lawson Road
Request:
Neighborhood Commercial to Commercial
Source:
Kenny Loux
PROPOSAL / REQUEST:
Land Use Plan
amendment in the Crystal Valley Planning District from Neighborhood Commercial
to Commercial. The Commercial category includes a broad range of retail and
wholesale sales of products, personal and professional services, and general
business activities. The
applicant would like to use an existing vacant building and graveled lot for a
used car lot and vehicle maintenance activities.
Prompted by this
Land Use Amendment request, the Planning Staff expanded the area of review to
include the entire Neighborhood Commercial extending southwest from the
Lawson-Sullivan Road intersection.
With these changes, 78% of the existing Neighborhood Commercial node
would be converted to Commercial.
It is thought that the additional area would make the boundaries more
logical and incorporate existing businesses.
EXISTING LAND USE
AND ZONING:
The property is
partially developed with a mobile home in the center of the lot and a metal
building located at the front of the lot currently zoned C-1 Neighborhood
Commercial District and 1.97 acres ± in size.
The application is in the Extraterritorial Planning Area and the area has
several non-conforming uses.
The land north of the site and on the opposite side of Lawson Road is
zoned R-2 -Single Family District consisting of several single family homes and
mobile homes situated on narrow lots close to Lawson Road because of the hilly
terrain rising from the roadway.
Northwest of the site is an area zoned C-1 -Neighborhood Commercial
District similar in terrain with additional homes, an abandoned multiple bay
coin carwash, and land zoned C-3 with a garage and a small auto/parts salvage
yard. Directly
east of the property is a CUP -Conditional Use Permit for the Crystal Volunteer
Fire Department.
Further east at the Lawson/Sullivan Road Intersection is a PCD with two
small business uses including Wickety Wax Candle Manufacturing and Tactfully
Done Upholstery. On
the opposite side of Sullivan Road are two small buildings, one a seasonal sno-cone
outlet and the other an office use, Custom Advertising Products, Inc.
Further southeast of the property are additional single family homes
fronting Lawson Road on narrow lots.
South of the site are several mobile homes on single family lots fronting
Minton Road and vacant wooded land.
Immediately west is a PCD for a seasonal sno-cone stand and mobile home.
Further to the west at Morehart Road is land zoned R-2 with several
single family homes on large lots.
Northwest of the property is additional R-2 land with an abandoned auto
sales building with a gravel lot, and a mobile home with a small auto/parts
salvage yard.
FUTURE LAND USE PLAN
AND RECENT AMENDMENTS:
June 1, 1999.
A change was made from Single Family to Neighborhood Commercial on the
south side of Lawson Road, west of Sullivan Road, expanding the existing
Neighborhood Commercial to including the applicant’s property for proposed
development.
The surrounding
areas are shown as Single Family.
A node of Neighborhood Commercial 6.4 acres ± in size exists at the
intersection of Sullivan and Lawson Roads.
This node expands west from Sullivan Road on the south side of Lawson
Road to include the applicant’s property.
MASTER STREET PLAN:
Lawson Road and Sullivan Road are shown as Minor
Arterials on the Master Street Plan.
The purpose of a Minor Arterial is to provide connections to and through
an urban area. Lawson
Road may
require dedication of right-of-way and may require street improvements.
Existing or proposed
Class I, II, or III bikeways are not in the immediate vicinity of the
development.
PARKS:
The property under
review is not located in a recognized Park Planning District and does not show
any existing or proposed parks in the area.
HISTORIC DISTRICTS:
There are no city
recognized historic districts that would be affected by this amendment.
CITY RECOGNIZED
NEIGHBORHOOD ACTION PLAN:
The property under
review is not located in an area covered by a City of Little Rock recognized
neighborhood action plan.
ANALYSIS:
This section of Lawson Road lies in a rural
area of Pulaski County and was added to the City’s Extraterritorial Planning
Jurisdiction March 1, 1988. The present Neighborhood Commercial was established
in 1992 to represent a small commercial node at the intersection of two minor
arterial streets. Typically
commercial areas are located at major intersections and limited to approximately
five acres. The
Neighborhood Commercial area was chosen to provide low intensity commercial
activities in the area while protecting the area’s rural character. Originally
(1992) the area shown as Neighborhood Commercial was 2.4 acres ± in size and on
June 1, 1999 Ordinance #18,030 was approved expanding the Neighborhood
Commercial area from the southwest corner of the Sullivan-Lawson Road
intersection towards the applicant’s property which was shown as Single
Family. This
expansion was initiated at the request of the owner of the land in 1999, not the
present applicant. The
expansion added 4.2 acres ± of Neighborhood Commercial bringing the total
amount shown to 6.4 acres ±, more than double that of 1999.
The existing Neighborhood Commercial area is
surrounded by numerous single family homes in a rural atmosphere.
Because of steep terrain on the north side of the roadway, a majority of
the homes have situated themselves close to the roadway giving this section of
Lawson Road a rural community atmosphere.
The existing area presently shown as Neighborhood Commercial is more than
adequate for area residents at this time.
Due to the topography of the area developments on the north side of
Lawson Road will have to be smaller scale to prevent major cuts or fills, which
is supportive of the Neighborhood Commercial concept.
Also, when future street improvements are made to Lawson Road topography
will prevent large commercial development from occurring on the north side of
the property.
Showing this land as Commercial would result
in a strip of Commercial shown on the south side of Lawson Road.
Identifying a strip of Commercial could lead to large scale high
intensity strip commercial development, which could be incompatible with
adjacent uses. Incompatible
uses could result in pressure to expand the Commercial in the area resulting in
larger scale more intense uses.
Due to the topography north of Lawson Road large scale Commercial uses
will be limited unless major cut and fill operations are undergone.
Further changes could also result in a higher intensity Commercial node
at the Stewart and Lawson Roads intersection.
Since the area in question is shown as Neighborhood Commercial, uses
could be limited in scale and intensity leading to more desirable commercial
activities. The
Neighborhood Commercial shown does indicate a strip of Commercial on the south
side of Lawson Road and could lead strip commercial.
However, since it is Neighborhood Commercial, scale and intensity can be
limited making future development more compatible with surrounding land uses.
Limiting uses in this area to Neighborhood Commercial will be more
compatible with surrounding Single Family and the existing Neighborhood
Commercial in the area.
Almost 90%, 5.6
acres ±, of the Neighborhood Commercial shown is being used for commercial or
office use. Generally
the businesses located in the area are not targeted at the immediate area
residents. Auto
repair, candle manufacturing, scrap yards, advertising agencies, and upholstery
typically draw from a larger demographic area as compared to the local sno-cone
shops. In turn
showing this area as Commercial might better recognize the existing businesses
in the area and facilitate similar businesses in the future.
However, in the area there is an abundance of land shown as Commercial or
Mixed Commercial Industrial.
This Neighborhood Commercial area makes up just 25% of the 33 acres ±
identified for commercial uses within a mile of the site.
Uses of higher intensities have been centered at the intersection of
Marsh and Lawson Roads while the lower intensity uses have been centered at the
present location of the Neighborhood Commercial.
Changing this area to a higher intensity use could be considered
premature due the amount of Commercial shown less than a mile west of the
property. The
land west of the application is more suitable for Commercial activities focusing
on a larger demographic area.
NEIGHBORHOOD
COMMENTS:
Notices were sent to
the following neighborhood associations: Crystal Valley Property Owners
Association and the Plantation House Homeowners Association.
Staff has received four comments from area residents.
None are in support, two are opposed to the change, and two were neutral.
STAFF
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Staff believes the
change is not appropriate.
A Neighborhood Commercial area provides low intensity uses to a local
area. Higher
intensity commercial uses would be incompatible with the existing rural
residential character of the community, and land is shown less than a mile west
that can facilitate the applicant’s request.
PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION:
(DECEMBER 2, 2004)
The item was placed on the
consent agenda for deferral to the January 20, 2005 Planning Commission meeting.
A motion was made to wavier the by-laws for a five-day notice to defer
prior to the Planning Commission meeting.
That motion was made and approved with a vote of 9 ayes, 0 noes, and 2
absent. A
motion was made to approve the consent agenda and was approved with a vote of 9
ayes, 0 noes and 2 absent.
STAFF
UPDATE:
The applicant has
not submitted any alternatives or scheduled any meetings with Staff regarding
this application. The application remains unchanged.
PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION:
(JANUARY 20, 2005)
The
item was placed on the consent agenda for deferral to the March 3, 2005, 2004
Planning Commission meeting.
A motion was made to waive the by-laws for a five-day notice to defer
prior to the Planning Commission meeting.
That motion was made and approved with a vote of 10 ayes, 0 noes, and 1
absent. A
motion was made to approve the consent agenda and was approved with a vote of 10
ayes, 0 noes and 1 absent.
STAFF
UPDATE:
The applicant has not submitted any
alternatives or scheduled any meetings with Staff regarding this application.
The application remains unchanged.